Continually Minimise IR35 Risk

24th January 2010

We can assist in this process, by reviewing your current contractual terms and working practices, to assess “IR35 tax risk” and then suggest improvements.

HMRC provide an online tool to assess your employment status:

The following badges of trade are some of the factors HM Revenue & Customs would use in assessing whether income from a particular contract is subject to the IR35 tax rules:

Badges of Trade

 

 

Indicative of Self-Employment

 (Contract for Service)

(ie: IR35 does not apply)

Indicative of Employment

(Contract of Service)

(ie: IR35 does apply)

 Control
You have the right to decide how, when and where a job is done.

Leading test cases: ECR Consulting Ltd, Castle Construction (Chesterfield) Ltd, Ready Mixed Concrete.

Close directional supervision by your client (master – servant relationship). Staff rules and regulations. Client can dismiss you.

Leading test cases: Autoclenz Ltd, Andrews, Stagecraft Ltd.

Personal Services
You have the substitution or delegation right to decide by whom a job is done (ie it is not a personal service).

Leading test cases: ECR Consulting Ltd, Community Dental Centres Ltd, MBF Design Services Ltd, Express and Echo Publications Ltd.

Single named worker only, or non matching contracts either side of agency, providing a personal service

Leading test case: Dragonfly Consultancy Ltd.

Basis of remuneration
Remunerated on a project basis, or at a fixed price. Remunerated on a time basis.
Provision of equipment
 You supply large or expensive equipment, and may work from a dedicated area of your own premises. Provision of only small or no equipment. Work at client’s premises.

Leading test case: Hall v Lorimer

Trading structure
Trade with more than one client at a time, or work on short successive assignments with different clients.

Leading test case: MBF Design Services Ltd, Market Investigations Ltd.

Long term assignments with the
same client. Working for previous employer, within the public sector or as an officer of the client.
Financial risk
A loss can be suffered. All rejected work to be corrected at your own cost. Penalty clauses. The opportunity exists to make a larger profit from sound management.

Leading test case: J and C Windows.

No financial exposure. All rejected work to be corrected at your client’s cost.
Business organisation
Own premises, letterheads, domain, website, training, other employees, insurance etc. Quoting for jobs in advance. Advertising None.
Terms of engagement
Contracts and actual working practices which are consistent with beneficial badges of trade. If engaged through an agency, then both contracts must match. Contracts which do not record the above beneficial badges of trade, no contracts at all, or actual work practises which differ from those recorded (sham).

Leading test case: Autoclenz Ltd.

Employee rights
 None. Typical employee benefits and statutory protection (eg paid holidays, sick pay, etc).
Part and parcel of the organisation
Appear and behave differently to employees. Re: staff parties, training days, e-mail address, canteen, parking space, etc.

Leading test cases: Novasoft Ltd,.

Appear and behave the same as employees.

Leading test cases: Dragonfly Consultancy Ltd, Future Online Ltd.

Mutuality of obligations and intentions
No obligation to offer and accept work over a period of time.

Leading test cases: ECR Consulting Ltd, Larkstar Data Ltd.

Mutual committment to offer and accept work over a period of time.

Leading test cases: Airfix Footwear Ltd, Synaptek Ltd.

The overall picture of employment status, and hence your IR35 status, would ultimately be determined by a court of law based on the “balance of probabilities” test; and not based on the “beyond reasonable doubt” test which is the yardstick by which most Tax Inspectors wrongly arrive at an opinion. In deciding IR35 status, a tribunal would arrive at a decision after having ‘painted a picture from the accumulation of detail’. If the detail gives a balanced picture, then the mutual intention of both parties will be the deciding factor.  This is why the detail is important and this is an area where we can offer guidance.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Richard Alecock
18th October 2018 HMRC defer MTD for businesses with more complex requirements

HMRC have updated  MTD for businesses with more complex requirements The exception is a small minority of VAT-registered businesses with more complex requirements. As part of planning for the VAT pilot, HMRC have made the decision to delay mandation for these customers until 1 October 2019 to ensure there is sufficient time to test the…

Read More »

Victor Courdelle
15th October 2018 If HMRC Can’t Say, Who Can? – Records Required for ‘Cash Accounting for VAT’ Under MTD

Reference to VAT Notices 700/21, 700/22 and 731 suggests that a business using Cash Accounting for VAT under Making Tax Digital will be required to:- Maintain digital accounting records at transaction level: Keep a digital VAT account using Accrual accounting; Cross reference Monies Received and Paid against individual Sales and Purchase invoices within their digital…

Read More »

Thomas Carter
12th October 2018 How to choose a business structure

Are you thinking about setting up a business?  If so, one of the first decisions you will need to make is that of business structure. The main business structures are: sole trader, partnership, limited liability company, and limited liability partnership (LLP). Sole trader – This is the easiest set up, with very little in the way of red…

Read More »

Richard Alecock
11th October 2018 Why a start up business should complete a business plan

A business plan is a written document that describes your business. By committing your thoughts to paper, you can understand your business better and also map specific courses of action that need to be taken to improve your business. It covers objectives, strategies, sales, marketing and financial forecasts. A business plan can help you to:…

Read More »

Richard Alecock
11th October 2018 Making Tax Digital, VAT and newly registered businesses

All VAT registered businesses with a turnover over the current VAT registration threshold of £85,000 will be required to comply with the Making Tax Digital (MTD) record keeping and reporting requirements for VAT periods which start on and after 1st April 2019. Where a business is VAT registered but has turnover under £85,000 at April…

Read More »

Matilda Mawson
5th October 2018 Have you elected not to claim child benefit?

You may wish to consider the implication this could have on your state pension in later life. Following the introduction of the high income child benefit charge in January 2013 many new parents have decided not to make a claim for child benefit as their individual income is well above the threshold to be fully…

Read More »