Great audit expectations

29th October 2018

No audit sets out to conclude with total confidence that a set of financial statements are 100% free from any misstatement. To do so would belie the technological reality and scale of modern business; auditors would likely become a permanent fixture at client premises to review every single business transaction and audit would become an uneconomic exercise for all concerned.

Instead, auditors set out to form an opinion as to whether the accounts present a true and fair view and are not materially misstated.

The expectation gap refers to the difference between what the public and other financial statement users perceive auditors’ responsibilities to be and what auditors believe their responsibilities entail.

Recent negative media coverage of audit (for example, following the collapse of Carillion) has only served to highlight this gap. The most recent response came last week from the Audit Quality Forum (AQF), which is to conduct an independent review into how audit can better serve the public interest.

This will coincide with other reviews of the sector currently ongoing from the Competition and Markets Authority (dominance of the Big Four), the Kingman review (future of the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) and the FRC itself (‘developments in audit’ programme).

Audit undoubtedly serves a crucial purpose in modern business and will continue to do so in the future. We recognise the clear benefits it brings to our clients. However, auditing must continue to evolve and improve, not only in how it is performed but also in its communication and engagement with all stakeholders.



 
Other items in Audit and Assurance
 
Ernesta Petkeviciute
29th June 2020 Guidance on pension scheme financial reports and audit featuring Covid-19

A joint guidance has been published by ICAS, ICAEW and PRAG on pension scheme financial reports and audit, with a large focus on Covid-19 matters.   The impact of Covid-19 pandemic on the control environment of pension schemes is explored, to help auditors navigate the additional challenges they are likely to experience and help them…

Read More »

Jaimie King
14th April 2020 Covid-19 and stock-take attendance

Companies that require their accounts to be audited, and hold significant levels of stock at their year-end, expect a visit from their auditors annually to perform test counts of their stock.   However, during the current lockdown, auditors are considering other ways to gain the assurance they need over the stock levels held. Some suggestions…

Read More »

Jaimie King
13th August 2019 Charity accounts assurance

Whether unincorporated, a charitable company or a CIO (charitable incorporated organisation), charities are required to have certain levels of assurance over their financial statements depending on their size. The limits are much smaller than companies, meaning that many charities require some sort of external scrutiny. The requirements by size are as follows: Income up to…

Read More »

Jaimie King
7th June 2019 Digitalising stocktaking

As the world becomes more digital, it leaves us wondering where further efficiencies could be achieved through switching to more high-tech methods. One possible area for auditors is stocktaking. For an audited entity with significant levels of stock at the year end, it is likely the auditor will want to perform test counts of the…

Read More »

Jonathan Moore
6th June 2019 Don’t take record keeping for granted

It is common for entities who undertake research and development to receive grant funding for projects that they undertake. Grants will often be paid on the basis of expenditure incurred or a proportion thereon and may be awarded with certain conditions attached.   One such condition for grants above a certain level will be the…

Read More »

Daniel Christopher
29th October 2018 Great audit expectations

No audit sets out to conclude with total confidence that a set of financial statements are 100% free from any misstatement. To do so would belie the technological reality and scale of modern business; auditors would likely become a permanent fixture at client premises to review every single business transaction and audit would become an…

Read More »