HMRC loses IR35 case

5th April 2018

 

A contractor in the construction industry, Mark Daniels, has won his appeal against HMRC. In MDCM Ltd v Revenue & Customs, HMRC were defending their decision that a contract between Mr Daniels’ personal service company MDMC Ltd and recruitment agency Solutions, which provided his services to Structure Tone Ltd,  should have been caught by IR35.

 

The first tier tribunal found the contract to be one of self-employment and so Mr Daniels’ appeal was successful, despite there being no financial risk to Mr Daniels and no substitution permitted. The most important factors include that he was not controlled by the end user and there was no holiday or sick pay or any other employment benefits.  One of the more interesting points was that being paid a fixed day rate indicated self-employment, so was in Mr Daniels favour.

 

We will have to wait to see if HMRC appeal against this decision. It does however demonstrate that the rules surrounding IR35 are complex if HMRC were unable to prove their decision was correct.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Angelica Hunt
19th April 2021 HMRC – Tax refund delays

A number of our clients are experiencing long delays in receiving tax refunds from HMRC.   HMRC attribute these to the need for them to perform security checks in order to combat fraudulent claims.  In some cases, HMRC need more information in order to verify genuine claims.   They may issue a verification letter, either…

Read More »

Ian Piper
15th April 2021 2021 SME Growth: Revenge Spending?

As we pass the Covid-19’s first anniversary of its impact on our area’s economy, accounts of local SME’s are now starting to show part of the damage they have experienced through the lock-downs and associated restrictive measures. Thankfully, through Government financial help and the nimble footwork of businesses adapting to survive, the overall effect upon…

Read More »

Jaimie King
15th April 2021 Life after CBILS: The Recovery Loan Scheme

The government-backed Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme closed on 31st March to new applicants. Thankfully, the government has put in place further support for businesses, to follow this.   The Recovery Loan Scheme – Government backed loans, 3 months – up to 6 years depending on the product – Up to £10m, no cap on…

Read More »

Vanessa Pearson
26th March 2021 6 April: A Guide to Off-Payroll Working Tax Rules

The proposed new rules apply regarding who determines IR35 status for freelancers hired by medium and large companies are imminent. Our Brief Guide will help find out how this affects you and what you can do: A Brief Guide to Off-Payroll Working Blog entry by: Vanessa Pearson

Read More »

Ben Kilby
25th March 2021 I hear a rumour…

I hear a rumour that Lloyds Agricultural banking team based in Edinburgh has been disbanded and merged within other teams around the country. Although some within the new regional teams may have some knowledge of agriculture it has been suggested that customers felt that this was not important. It seems that the agricultural specialism within…

Read More »

Fiona Mann
24th March 2021 Making Tax Digital – the next steps

Our MTD Group have produced Issue 5 of their newsletter giving details of Making Tax Digital (MTD) as it continues.   So if you are unsure of what to do next, our newsletter has information and advice how to proceed.  Don’t delay however as penalties will be introduced if submission deadlines are missed.   W&P_MTD5…

Read More »