HMRC loses IR35 case

5th April 2018

 

A contractor in the construction industry, Mark Daniels, has won his appeal against HMRC. In MDCM Ltd v Revenue & Customs, HMRC were defending their decision that a contract between Mr Daniels’ personal service company MDMC Ltd and recruitment agency Solutions, which provided his services to Structure Tone Ltd,  should have been caught by IR35.

 

The first tier tribunal found the contract to be one of self-employment and so Mr Daniels’ appeal was successful, despite there being no financial risk to Mr Daniels and no substitution permitted. The most important factors include that he was not controlled by the end user and there was no holiday or sick pay or any other employment benefits.  One of the more interesting points was that being paid a fixed day rate indicated self-employment, so was in Mr Daniels favour.

 

We will have to wait to see if HMRC appeal against this decision. It does however demonstrate that the rules surrounding IR35 are complex if HMRC were unable to prove their decision was correct.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Matilda Mawson
24th February 2020 An update for NHS staff on the annual allowance charge for 2019/20

Current Issues The introduction of the tapered pension annual allowance from 6 April 2016 has been a contentious issue for many, in particular senior NHS staff members. The legislation change means that, for high income individuals, the annual pension allowance may be reduced from £40,000 to a minimum of £10,000. Pension inputs in excess of…

Read More »

Jodie Tarbin
24th February 2020 How taking a pension lump sum could save you money

  If you reached state pension age after 6 April 2016 and deferred taking your pension, you will receive a higher weekly amount when you start receiving it. However, if you reached state pension age before 6 April 2016 there is a second option, which is to receive a state pension lump sum rather than…

Read More »

Vanessa Pearson
18th February 2020 6 April: A Guide to Off-Payroll Working Tax Rules

There are less than two months to go until the proposed new rules apply regarding who determines IR35 status for freelancers hired by medium and large companies. Our Brief Guide will help find out how this affects you and what you can do   A Brief Guide to Off-payroll Working_Feb 2020

Read More »

Matilda Mawson
14th February 2020 5th April: Pre Year End Tax Planning

As we approach the end of another personal tax year (5 April 2020), there are a number of tax planning opportunities for individuals to consider to ensure best use is made of currently available allowances, exemptions and favourable tax rates:   Tax year end planning Brief Guide_Feb 2020   With the 2020 Budget also just…

Read More »

Jaimie King
12th February 2020 Successful tax refund for grain silo treatment

A successful legal case claiming that grain silos should be treated as plant and machinery for corporation tax purposes – rather than land and buildings – has resulted in a successful tax refund claim by Whitings.   The claim was submitted following precedent set in the legal case, and resulted in a substantial tax refund…

Read More »

Andrew Band
3rd February 2020 Whitings Annual Farming Seminar – Invite

  Clients in the farming sector, related sectors and professional contacts are invited to attend the ninth annual Whiting & Partners Farming Seminar. This is being held on Wednesday 25 March 2020, at the Maltings in Ely:   A5_Flyer_Farming_Seminar20   Presenters from the Andersons Centre will once again look forward to the year ahead, post…

Read More »