IR35 Test Case: BBC presenter presented with £419k back taxes bill

19th February 2018

 

BBC Look North presenter Christa Ackroyd has lost a high profile test case with HMRC over whether or not IR35 legislation applied to her contract. The main terms of this contract, between her personal service company and the BBC, were:

  • 7 year contract
  • Providing tv presenting services for 225 days pa

 

The First Tier Tribunal appeal judge ruled that these terms were akin to ‘employment status’ in nature, due to the following key factors:

  • No substitution clause
  • Mutuality of obligations
  • High degree of control
  • High volume of years and days engaged
  • Contract only terminable by material breach
  • Co-presenter on Look North program engaged as an employee.

 

This ruling enabled HMRC to validly apply IR35 deemed salary principles and assess back taxes of £419,151, covering 7 tax years.

 

As engagements with public sector clients since 6 April 2017 are now subject to an IR35 review by the end client, the precedent this test case sets is not as helpful to HMRC as is often the case. But, as always, contractors should always try and strengthen their contractual terms and actual work practices from an IR35 perspective, including getting a substitution clause included in their contract.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Keith Day
7th February 2019 Businesses urged to prepare for post-Brexit Customs

HMRC is urging VAT-registered UK businesses which trade exclusively with the EU to be prepared for a no deal Brexit.   In a letter sent to 145,000 affected businesses, HMRC explains changes to Customs, Excise and VAT procedures in the ‘unlikely event’ that the UK leaves the EU without a Brexit deal.   HMRC’s letter…

Read More »

Adrian Mackenzie
7th February 2019 Beware of pension investment scams

The Insolvency Service has urged individuals saving for retirement to protect their pension pots from criminals and ‘negligent trustees’.   Research carried out by the Service found that criminals use a range of tactics to convince savers to part with their funds, including persuading individuals to access their pension and invest in unregulated schemes.  …

Read More »

Victor Courdelle
7th February 2019 MTD for VAT – pilot extended to all eligible businesses

  HMRC has extended its Making Tax Digital for VAT (MTDfV) pilot scheme to all eligible businesses. For most businesses, compliance with the regulations is mandated for VAT return periods beginning on or after 1 April 2019. However, MTDfV for some ‘more complex’ businesses has been deferred until 1 October 2019. This deferral applies to:…

Read More »

Stephen Malkin
1st February 2019 MTD for VAT: Which Bridging Software?

As we approach the 1 April 2019 deadline for the introduction of MTD compliant VAT submissions, many businesses will at last be focusing on what solution they should adopt.   If their current bookkeeping system does not already have an upgrade that automatically provides this new functionality, they will be considering adopting ‘bridging software’.   Looking through…

Read More »

Ian Piper
18th January 2019 CryptoCurrency Taxation: HMRC close loophole?

HMRC are not known for being ahead of the curve, so trying to find official guidance on how exchange gains from selling bitcoin, and other crypto currencies, is expected to be self-assessed and taxed, was always going to be ‘problematic’. At the time of first researching this, the latest HMRC guidance was published in 3…

Read More »

Peter Brown
13th January 2019 5 things you need to know about Making Tax Digital

  Making Tax Digital (MTD) is the hot topic this year. It’s one of the most fundamental changes to the UK tax system since the introduction of self-assessment. From April 2019, VAT registered businesses with a turnover of over £85,000 will be required to keep records using software approved by HMRC.  We have condensed the…

Read More »