IR35 Test Case: BBC presenter presented with £419k back taxes bill

19th February 2018

 

BBC Look North presenter Christa Ackroyd has lost a high profile test case with HMRC over whether or not IR35 legislation applied to her contract. The main terms of this contract, between her personal service company and the BBC, were:

  • 7 year contract
  • Providing tv presenting services for 225 days pa

 

The First Tier Tribunal appeal judge ruled that these terms were akin to ‘employment status’ in nature, due to the following key factors:

  • No substitution clause
  • Mutuality of obligations
  • High degree of control
  • High volume of years and days engaged
  • Contract only terminable by material breach
  • Co-presenter on Look North program engaged as an employee.

 

This ruling enabled HMRC to validly apply IR35 deemed salary principles and assess back taxes of £419,151, covering 7 tax years.

 

As engagements with public sector clients since 6 April 2017 are now subject to an IR35 review by the end client, the precedent this test case sets is not as helpful to HMRC as is often the case. But, as always, contractors should always try and strengthen their contractual terms and actual work practices from an IR35 perspective, including getting a substitution clause included in their contract.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Matilda Mawson
19th July 2019 Changes to Entrepreneurs Relief from 6 April 2019

Entrepreneurs’ relief allows a reduced rate of capital gains tax on disposals of all or part of your business assets. The reduced tax rate is 10% on up to £10 million of lifetime gains. There have been a number of significant changes to entrepreneurs’ relief in the last year, tightening the rules on qualifying conditions…

Read More »

Ernesta Petkeviciute
19th July 2019 New SRA accounting rules – what’s changing?

The current Accounts Rules are made up of over 40 detailed requirements, making it difficult for firms to fully understand what is required of them, as well as giving firms no flexibility to adapt them to their own practices and decide how best to look after client’s money.   The new rules coming into effect…

Read More »

Vanessa Pearson
15th July 2019 IR35: private sector off-payroll rules for contractors

This week HMRC have published draft legislation that will affect private sector personal services companies (PSCs)  from 6 April 2020. PSC’s supplying services to medium or large-sized organisations will no longer decide if they are employed or self-employed, the end engager will assess this. If caught by these rules, known as IR35, employment taxes and…

Read More »

Paul Jefferson
15th July 2019 Company car tax changes – Government will remove BIK company car tax on Electric Vehicles from 2020/21

The government has provided positive news for Company car drivers announcing that a pure electric vehicle (EV) will no longer pay benefit-in-kind (BIK) tax in 2020/21 following a review which looks set to boost sales of emissions-free cars. HM Treasury’s response to its review of the fallout from the roll-out of the Worldwide Harmonised Light…

Read More »

Barbara Nicholas
9th July 2019 31 July: Can you elect to reduce your tax payment?

Most individuals who are required to prepare and submit a self-assessment tax return to HM Revenue & Customs in each tax year should now be preparing for their next half-yearly tax payment which is due by July 31.   This tax is the second payment-on-account for the 2018/19 tax year. It is automatically calculated as…

Read More »

Jaimie King
5th July 2019 Utilising the share premium account

For some privately owned companies, negative profit and loss reserves means that they are unable to pay out dividends as they do not have enough distributable reserves. However, they might have a significant share premium reserve, which is a non-distributable reserve. The Companies Act 2006 allows a private company to utilise the share premium account…

Read More »