Preserving EIS Status

30th November 2016

EIS:  Growth Shares and Preference.

Abingdon Health Ltd v HMRC TC05525

This was an interesting case, and a warning for the unwary. The issue at stake was whether HMRC’s withdrawal of EIS relief as a result of a preference created by a new class of growth share was reasonable.

The taxpayer company sought EIS relief in respect of three rounds of subscriptions for ‘preferred’ ordinary £1 shares that took place between March 2012 and February 2014. Although named ‘preferred’ shares, the ordinary shares in fact ranked pari passu with all shares in the company at the time of Rounds One and Two; HMRC accepted the company’s application for EIS relief in respect of those rounds. Between the second and third rounds, the company issued growth shares to certain key employees, and the company’s articles of association were amended to provide for the new class of share. The changes to the articles of association introduced a liquidation preference, so that, on a return of assets on a liquidation, capital reduction or otherwise, the holders of ordinary shares were paid in priority to holders of growth shares, up to the amount of a hurdle (£8,800,000).  The company subsequently applied for EIS relief in respect of Round Three. HMRC rejected the application and withdrew the EIS relief previously authorised in respect of Rounds One and Two, on the basis that the creation of the growth shares meant that the ordinary shares carried a preference so that the requirements for EIS were not met.

The tribunal held that the ordinary shares carried a preferential right to assets on a winding up during the restricted period, so the shares were not qualifying shares for EIS purposes. It considered that the preferential right existed regardless of whether the hurdle was reached. It also held that the preferential right was not so contingent as not to be meaningful, and therefore the company could not rely on the exemption in HMRC’s guidance for preferences which are purely theoretical.

Blog post by: Jeannette Hume.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Lucy Bayliss
11th April 2019 £10 a day from the 1st May!

If you submitted your tax return after the filing deadline of 31 January, or you still have not submitted your tax return, then you will automatically be fined £100 for missing the deadline.   In February, HMRC announced that they would be delaying issuing the late filing penalty notices due to Brexit. They have now…

Read More »

Matilda Mawson
10th April 2019 Has your claim for marriage allowance transfer been refused?

  HMRC have recently attempted to remove a marriage allowance transfer for a couple, where the transferor had less than the 10% personal allowance unused. This treatment is incorrect as outlined below:   Background to the transfer The marriage allowance transfer was introduced from 5 April 2015 onwards and allows a person to transfer 10%…

Read More »

Lisa Smith
9th April 2019 Digital Records for VAT – HMRC Guidance published

  From 1 April 2019, most businesses with a taxable turnover above £85,000 are required to follow the rules for Making Tax Digital for VAT.  As a result, HMRC has published new guidance on record keeping, which  explains what records a business needs to keep digitally if it has signed up for Making Tax Digital…

Read More »

Ian Piper
9th April 2019 R&D Tax Relief: HMRC Try to Tackle Abuse

  Many companies, not just those in the tech industry, will have benefitted from the generosity of R&D tax relief. Eligible R&D expenditure can be inflated by a notional 230% uplift, and a refund of tax claimed on tax that was never paid in the first place. Perhaps not unsurprisingly, HMRC have identified abuses of…

Read More »

Adrian Mackenzie
25th March 2019 When doing nothing is best

From time to time, stock markets go through periods of uncertainty. This could be down to some poor economic news or perhaps due to a political crisis.  The sharp falls that can be experienced at such times are understandably unsettling for investors. They can even tempt some to change their long-term plan by selling their…

Read More »

Thomas Carter
21st March 2019 Preparing for Brexit – Do you trade within the EU?

Your UK business may need an Economic Operator Registration and Identification (EORI) number if we leave the EU with no deal.   What is an EORI number?   An EORI number is a unique identifying number assigned to individual importers and exporters to track trade between the EU and non-EU countries. It’s used during Customs…

Read More »