Public Sector contractor wins IR35 case

18th June 2018

HMRC have lost a second IR35 case this year, and their second case against the same contractor, putting into doubt their own understanding of the IR35 rules. Ian Wells, director of personal service company Jensal Software Limited provided his services to the Department of Work and Pensions via a recruitment agency during 2012 and 2013.

HMRC would have been keen to win a case against a public sector contractor to bolster the IR35 reforms that began on 1 April 2017. However, the tribunal judge found several factors that meant the contract was outside IR35.

Mr Wells was not subject to the level of control that would constitute a contract of employment.

A clause in the contract allowed a substitute to be provided, and although not utilised, meant the balance was shifted away from employment. In fact, Mr Wells admitted he had requested the addition of such a clause which HMRC insisted proved the clause was a sham. Interestingly, the judge reasoned that inserting a clause did not negate the right to use it and rely on it.

HMRC generally view all public sector contracts to have Mutuality of Obligation – an obligation on both parties to provide and accept work. Judge Jennifer Dean decided there was not enough of an obligation to demonstrate a contract of employment.

 With HMRC currently consulting on private sector contractors, their decision to pursue this case casts doubt over their ability to recognise whether a contractor belongs inside or outside IR35.

 

 



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Megan Turner
4th June 2020 Charity Commission: Reporting on matters of material significance

The Charity Commission released updated guidelines in April 2020 for auditors and independent examiners. This was based around the statutory duty to report to the charity regulators in the UK on matters of material significance.   The three main changes in this updated guidance are as follows: confirmation that difficulties in carrying out an audit…

Read More »

Steven Denton
1st June 2020 HMRC Furlough Claim Update 29th May 2020

From 1st July, whilst still appreciating the benefits of the Furlough Scheme, employers will be able to benefit from the option of bringing employees back to work on a part time basis. This is one month earlier than had previously been announced.   Whilst working, employers will be required to pay their employees at their…

Read More »

Paul Jefferson
22nd May 2020 Dividend update

It is common practice for director/shareholders to be paid a modest salary through PAYE and pay the balance of their remuneration in dividends.  This of course is perfectly permissible if the company has profits available to distribute to shareholders and there is no breach of directors’ duty.  Unfortunately, the dramatic effect that the Coronavirus is…

Read More »

Lisa Smith
19th May 2020 Covid-19 –Statutory Sick Pay Rebate Scheme

The Government have announced that the Statutory Sick Pay Rebate Scheme, which will enable employers with fewer than 250 employees to claim Coronavirus-related Statutory Sick Pay will launch online on 26 May 2020.   Employers are eligible to use the scheme if:   they’re claiming for an employee who’s eligible for sick pay due to…

Read More »

Nick Edgley
19th May 2020 Company cars and fuel during COVID-19

If you are an employee with a company car, and maybe fuel provided, it is worthwhile considering giving up the car, or fuel, during the current pandemic if you are working from home or furloughed.   A company car benefit in kind (BIK) is a set amount based on the list price and emissions regardless…

Read More »

Ian Piper
18th May 2020 Covid-19: Companies House dissolutions now put on hold

Like many Government departments, Companies House have relaxed various compliance requirements to support businesses to get through this Covid-19 period. In their latest announcement, they are making the following temporary changes to their strike off policies:   Voluntary (Form DS01 submitted) Strike Off Applications – Process halted after notice published in London Gazette. Automatic Dissolutions…

Read More »