Public Sector contractor wins IR35 case

18th June 2018

HMRC have lost a second IR35 case this year, and their second case against the same contractor, putting into doubt their own understanding of the IR35 rules. Ian Wells, director of personal service company Jensal Software Limited provided his services to the Department of Work and Pensions via a recruitment agency during 2012 and 2013.

HMRC would have been keen to win a case against a public sector contractor to bolster the IR35 reforms that began on 1 April 2017. However, the tribunal judge found several factors that meant the contract was outside IR35.

Mr Wells was not subject to the level of control that would constitute a contract of employment.

A clause in the contract allowed a substitute to be provided, and although not utilised, meant the balance was shifted away from employment. In fact, Mr Wells admitted he had requested the addition of such a clause which HMRC insisted proved the clause was a sham. Interestingly, the judge reasoned that inserting a clause did not negate the right to use it and rely on it.

HMRC generally view all public sector contracts to have Mutuality of Obligation – an obligation on both parties to provide and accept work. Judge Jennifer Dean decided there was not enough of an obligation to demonstrate a contract of employment.

 With HMRC currently consulting on private sector contractors, their decision to pursue this case casts doubt over their ability to recognise whether a contractor belongs inside or outside IR35.

 

 



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Matilda Mawson
20th May 2019 Property allowance considerations: Joint properties held in unequal proportions

The property allowance was introduced on 5 April 2017, allowing a flat rate deduction of £1,000 to be claimed against property income, in lieu of keeping detailed records of expenses. This however, raises the question as to whether individuals renting out a joint property are required to make the same claim as one another. In…

Read More »

Bethan Hassey
20th May 2019 RSM’s Zorb Football Tournament

  On Thursday 16th May, Whitings attended RSM’s first ever Zorb Football Tournament in aid of the charity GeeWizz! After playing against 5 other firms, Whitings managed to finish 2nd overall based on goal difference.   It was a great event which helped raise money for a great cause. GeeWizz help support children and young…

Read More »

Matilda Mawson
16th May 2019 2019/20 Changes to Personal Tax and How It Could Save You Money

With the new tax year in full swing, we set out below some of the changes to various allowances and tax bands that affect how much tax you are paying: The personal allowance (the amount you can earn before you begin paying tax) has increased from £11,850 to £12,500. The basic rate tax band has…

Read More »

Jodie Tarbin
14th May 2019 PPR and Lettings Relief: an Update

Shortly following the last autumn budget, I published a blog “CGT Reliefs – Hit with Both Barrels!”, regarding the changes announced to the Principal Private Residence Relief (PPR) and letting relief rules.   HMRC have now published a consultation document, which can be found here: https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/capital-gains-tax-private-residence-relief-changes-to-the-ancillary-reliefs   The consultation period closes at 11:45pm on 1…

Read More »

Adrian Mackenzie
13th May 2019 Putting Time On Your Side

    How can you increase your chances of a successful investment in equities/stocks and shares ?   Please find attached a short paper by Fidelity International on this question.   One of the other most important points is the value in getting advice and making sure any investments chosen are appropriate to your individual…

Read More »

Lucy Bayliss
13th May 2019 Marriage Allowance

  As detailed in a recent blog written by Matilda Mawson (https://www.whitingandpartners.co.uk/has-your-claim-for-marriage-allowance-transfer-been-refused/), a ‘Marriage allowance’ was introduced from 5 April 2015 onwards, which allows a person 10% of their personal allowance to be given to their husband, wife or civil partner.   However, if you or your partner were born before 6 April 1935, you…

Read More »