Public Sector contractor wins IR35 case

18th June 2018

HMRC have lost a second IR35 case this year, and their second case against the same contractor, putting into doubt their own understanding of the IR35 rules. Ian Wells, director of personal service company Jensal Software Limited provided his services to the Department of Work and Pensions via a recruitment agency during 2012 and 2013.

HMRC would have been keen to win a case against a public sector contractor to bolster the IR35 reforms that began on 1 April 2017. However, the tribunal judge found several factors that meant the contract was outside IR35.

Mr Wells was not subject to the level of control that would constitute a contract of employment.

A clause in the contract allowed a substitute to be provided, and although not utilised, meant the balance was shifted away from employment. In fact, Mr Wells admitted he had requested the addition of such a clause which HMRC insisted proved the clause was a sham. Interestingly, the judge reasoned that inserting a clause did not negate the right to use it and rely on it.

HMRC generally view all public sector contracts to have Mutuality of Obligation – an obligation on both parties to provide and accept work. Judge Jennifer Dean decided there was not enough of an obligation to demonstrate a contract of employment.

 With HMRC currently consulting on private sector contractors, their decision to pursue this case casts doubt over their ability to recognise whether a contractor belongs inside or outside IR35.

 

 



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Ruth Pearson
25th February 2021 HMRC Advisory Fuel Rates

HMRC have issued the new advisory fuel rates (AFR) which come into effect from 1st March 2021.   They have increased by 1p per mile for petrol and diesel vehicles with engines of 1400-2000cc reflecting a small increase in fuel prices over the last quarter.   The advisory electricity rate for fully electric cars remains…

Read More »

Keith Day
19th February 2021 VAT deferral new payment scheme – join from 23 February

If you deferred paying VAT due in the period from 20‌‌ March to 30‌‌ June‌‌ 2020, you should pay it by 31‌‌ ‌March‌‌ ‌2021 if you can.   If you can’t afford to pay by 31‌‌ March‌‌ 2021, you can join the VAT deferral new payment scheme and pay your deferred VAT over a longer period.   The online service…

Read More »

Scott Butcher
19th February 2021 Deadline looms for CBILS & BBL schemes

We are now just over a month away from the 31st March 2021 deadline for applications for the Bounce Back Loan (BBL) and Coronavirus Business Interruption Loan Scheme (CBILS).   The schemes were introduced to provide businesses with much needed working capital during the global pandemic, businesses benefited from no capital repayments being required for…

Read More »

Fiona Mann
19th February 2021 News: HMRC announce no penalty charge for late Self Assessment

Today HMRC have announced that they will not be charging Self Assessment tax payers a 5% late payment penalty if they pay their tax, or set up a payment plan by 1 April 2021.   This year, because of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, HMRC is giving taxpayers more time to pay or set…

Read More »

Vanessa Pearson
18th February 2021 IR35 – HMRC announce ‘light touch’ approach to penalties

The new private sector off-payroll rules are due to start from 6 April 2021 and HMRC have published their latest guidance – here.   The changes move the responsibility for determining a contractor’s IR35 status from the worker’s personal service company to the end client engaging them, where the end client is a medium/large business.…

Read More »

Lisa Smith
11th February 2021 VAT payments deferred due to Coronavirus

If, due to Coronavirus, your business deferred VAT payments due between 20 March and 30 June 2020 and you still have payments to make, you can: pay the deferred VAT in full, on or before 31 March 2021, join the VAT deferral new payment scheme – the online service is open between 23 February and…

Read More »