VAT Recovery

29th September 2016

VAT on Motor Car Purchase: When is recovery of blocked VAT unblocked?
A recent tax tribunal case has brought some good news for businesses purchasing cars for business use and provided some clarification to the restrictions and requirements to qualify. Historically it has proven difficult to satisfy HMRC of their intention to not make motor cars available for private use. In addition, the tribunal addressed the question of de-minimis use, finding that minimal personal use, such as use of the car merely to enjoy or collect lunch whilst on a business journey, would not prejudice otherwise wholly business use.

In the case of Zone Contractors Ltd, the First-tier Tribunal (FTT) ruled that the restrictions imposed on the use of its motor cars were sufficient to prove that the company did not intend to make the vehicles available for private use. The claim was made that the input tax deduction was legitimate on the grounds that the cars were intended for use solely for business purposes and that any private use was prohibited. To support this assertion, the company informed HMRC that the terms of employment pursuant to which all staff were employed explicitly included an absolute prohibition of private use of company vehicles. Additionally, the cars were kept either on site or at the company offices overnight and were, therefore, not available for private journeys. The keys were generally kept in the company’s Birmingham office, although, on occasions, the vehicles might be left in London or on site. However, when in Birmingham the keys would be stored on hooks in the office. Each of the directors owned their own private car and these were used to commute to and from the office.

The main factor to the decision was the terms of the employment contract. These were explicit and binding in prohibiting employees from using company vehicles for private purposes. All members of staff, including the directors, signed the contract terms. The FTT, therefore, found that the staff were subject to a legal restriction on the private use of company vehicles. Further, the cars were intended to be stored overnight such that they were not available for the most common form of private use, namely travel to and from work.
The FTT rejected HMRC’s assertion that unless a taxpayer maintains mileage logs to evidence that there is, as a matter of fact, no actual private use, recovery of input tax recovery is not possible. It may be the case that mileage logs are either the best form of evidence or potentially even critical. However, the Court of Appeal made clear that legal restrictions are sufficient, particularly if supported by physical restrictions, such as requiring the cars to be stored overnight at company premises.

In the judgment of the FTT, the appellant had demonstrated that it did not have an intention to make the motor cars available for private use. Accordingly, it was entitled to the input tax it sought to recover.



 
Other items in Blogs
 
Vanessa Pearson
18th February 2020 6 April: A Guide to Off-Payroll Working Tax Rules

There are less than two months to go until the proposed new rules apply regarding who determines IR35 status for freelancers hired by medium and large companies. Our Brief Guide will help find out how this affects you and what you can do   A Brief Guide to Off-payroll Working_Feb 2020

Read More »

Matilda Mawson
14th February 2020 5th April: Pre Year End Tax Planning

As we approach the end of another personal tax year (5 April 2020), there are a number of tax planning opportunities for individuals to consider to ensure best use is made of currently available allowances, exemptions and favourable tax rates:   Tax year end planning Brief Guide_Feb 2020   With the 2020 Budget also just…

Read More »

Jaimie King
12th February 2020 Successful tax refund for grain silo treatment

A successful legal case claiming that grain silos should be treated as plant and machinery for corporation tax purposes – rather than land and buildings – has resulted in a successful tax refund claim by Whitings.   The claim was submitted following precedent set in the legal case, and resulted in a substantial tax refund…

Read More »

Andrew Band
3rd February 2020 Whitings Annual Farming Seminar – Invite

  Clients in the farming sector, related sectors and professional contacts are invited to attend the ninth annual Whiting & Partners Farming Seminar. This is being held on Wednesday 25 March 2020, at the Maltings in Ely:   A5_Flyer_Farming_Seminar20   Presenters from the Andersons Centre will once again look forward to the year ahead, post…

Read More »

Emily Haines
29th January 2020 2020 Vision

  The Association of Accounting Technicians (AAT) recently published an article focusing on the accounting trends and changes that will shape 2020 (with content from Xero).   BREXIT – What will the significant changes be that will affect your business and your cashflow? Will your business have to look further into the future with management…

Read More »

Vanessa Pearson
16th January 2020 Off-Payroll Working Rules: 11th hour reprieve?

Those personal service companies working in the private sector (referred to, variously, as freelancers, consultants or contractors) should now be aware that new tax rules will apply to them with effect from 6-Apr-20.  These rules, off-payroll working, aim to finally clamp down on the abuse of the Inland Revenue Press Release number 35 tax rules…

Read More »